Ticket #1198 (closed defect: wontfix)
Audio (via headphone jack) doesn't couple well to some line-inputs
| Reported by: | cwixon@… | Owned by: | hardware |
|---|---|---|---|
| Priority: | high | Milestone: | |
| Component: | hardware | Version: | GTA01Bv4 |
| Severity: | normal | Keywords: | |
| Cc: | buglog@… | Blocked By: | |
| Blocking: | Estimated Completion (week): | ||
| HasPatchForReview: | no | PatchReviewResult: | |
| Reproducible: |
Description
Most equipment with headphone jacks can be attached to a stereo system with a
suitable adapter. I have found that using a 2.5mm 4-conductor plug to 3.5mm
3-conductor stereo jack adapter to connect the Neo does not work in some
circumstances:
- it works fine when connected to regular stereo headphones
- it works fine when connected to some stereo line-in ports
- it makes loud, percussive, rhythmic noises (several times louder than the
content from the media player, for example) when connected to my car's line-in.
My car's built-in line-in jack is functional with all other equipment I have
tried, including a satellite radio receiver, and various MP3 players and PDAs I
have used in the past. The Neo is the only device that makes these loud noises,
and it happens regardless of whether the engine is running, whether the Neo is
plugged into a power adapter, or whether there is any (intended) sound coming
from the Neo.
As described above, the adapter I have is apparently wired correctly, because it
works with headphones and some other stereo connections. I originally thought
this was noise (of the sort encountered with intermittent/bad amplifier
connections), but continued listening at low volumes, without moving anything,
and the repetitive/rhythmic nature of the noises, indicate that this is
electronic noise of some kind, probably coming from the Neo.
I will try to find a cheap audio isolator (coupling transformer) in the next few
days to see if that makes any difference. And if not, I will make a recording
of the noise and upload it here for further diagnosis.

UPDATE.
It works PERFECTLY through a ground-loop isolator, this one from Radio Shack in
particular:
http://www.radioshack.com/product/index.jsp?productId=2062214
Part No. 270-054, US$16.99.
This suggests to me that there's probably a DC offset originating somewhere
(Car->Neo or Neo->Car) that the receiving device doesn't react well to. I don't
have a 'scope so I can't really verify which direction it comes from.
But in either case, it appears the audio output stage of the Neo is non-standard
to some extent, and I'm leaving this bug open for now.